| Tahun |
Aktris |
Film |
Peran |
| 1990 | Sheryl Lee Ralph | To Sleep with Anger | Linda |
| Tracy Arnold | Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer | Becky |
| Ethel Ayler | To Sleep with Anger | Hattie |
| Tisha Campbell-Martin | House Party | Sidney |
| Adrienne-Joi Johnson | House Party | Sharane |
| 1991 | Diane Ladd | Rambling Rose | Mother ‡ |
| Sheila McCarthy | Bright Angel | Nina |
| Deirdre O'Connell | Pastime | Inez Brice |
| Emma Thompson | Impromptu | Duchess D'Antan |
| Mary B. Ward | Hangin' with the Homeboys | Luna |
| 1992 | Alfre Woodard | Passion Fish | Chantelle |
| Brooke Adams | Gas Food Lodging | Nora |
| Sara Gilbert | Poison Ivy | Sylvie Cooper |
| Karen Sillas | Simple Men | Kate |
| Danitra Vance | Jumpin' at the Boneyard | Jeanette |
| 1993 | Lili Taylor | Household Saints | Teresa Carmela Santangelo |
| Lara Flynn Boyle | Equinox | Beverly Franks |
| Gua Ah-leh | The Wedding Banquet | Mrs. Gao |
| Lucinda Jenney | American Heart | Charlotte |
| Julianne Moore | Short Cuts | Marian Wyman |
| 1994 | Dianne Wiest | Bullets Over Broadway | Helen Sinclair † |
| V.S. Brodie | Go Fish | Ely |
| Carla Gallo | Spanking the Monkey | Toni Peck |
| Kelly Lynch | The Beans of Egypt, Maine | Roberta Bean |
| Brooke Smith | Vanya on 42nd Street | Sonya |
| 1995 | Mare Winningham | Georgia | Georgia Flood ‡ |
| Jennifer Lopez | My Family | Young Maria |
| Vanessa Redgrave | Little Odessa | Irina Shapira |
| Chloë Sevigny | Kids | Jennie |
| Celia Weston | Dead Man Walking | Mary Beth Percy |
| 1996 | Elizabeth Peña | Lone Star | Pilar Cruz |
| Mary Kay Place | Manny & Lo | Elaine |
| Queen Latifah | Set It Off | Cleopatra 'Cleo' Sims |
| Lili Taylor | Girls Town | Patti Lucci |
| Lily Tomlin | Flirting with Disaster | Mary Schlichting |
| 1997 | Debbi Morgan | Eve's Bayou | Mozelle Batiste Delacroix |
| Farrah Fawcett | The Apostle | Jessie Dewey |
| Amy Madigan | Loved | Brett Amerson |
| Miranda Richardson | The Apostle | Toosie |
| Patricia Richardson | Ulee's Gold | Connie Hope |
| 1998 | Lynn Redgrave | Gods and Monsters | Hanna ‡ |
| Stockard Channing | The Baby Dance | Rachel Luckman |
| Patricia Clarkson | High Art | Greta |
| Lisa Kudrow | The Opposite of Sex | Lucia DeLury |
| Joely Richardson | Under Heaven | Eleanor Dunston |
| 1999 | Chloë Sevigny | Boys Don't Cry | Lana Tisdel ‡ |
| Barbara Barrie | Judy Berlin | Sue Berlin |
| Vanessa Martinez | Limbo | Noelle De Angelo |
| Sarah Polley | Go | Ronna Martin |
| Jean Smart | Guinevere | Deborah Sloane |
